About this template
This is the requirement set behind Olive's research into restaurant loyalty platforms: 95 requirements in 18 sections. Nine sections cover the loyalty program itself, from earn rules, rewards and offers to guest profiles, campaigns, POS and ordering integration, gift cards, fraud controls and franchise management. Nine cover the platform and the vendor behind it, from automation and integrations to contract terms.
It is written for marketing, IT and operations leaders choosing a loyalty platform for a restaurant brand, from a single concept to a multi-brand franchise system. Each section below says why it matters and how far apart vendors are on it in the research.
How to use it
Start with the sections, not the requirements. Decide which sections carry the most weight for your brand, then go through the requirements in each one and drop what does not apply. A brand without a gift card program may set stored value aside; a franchise system will weigh multi-brand management and franchise settlement heavily.
Put the same list to every vendor, in the same words, and ask for a score and evidence on each line. A requirement list only compares vendors fairly when every vendor answers the same questions.
Restaurant loyalty
These nine sections cover the loyalty program a guest sees and the controls a brand needs behind it: how guests earn, what they redeem, the offers and campaigns that bring them back, how they are recognized at the register and online, gift cards, fraud and liability, and running the program across franchisees and brands. Most platforms cover points, rewards and basic offers. The gaps open in POS and ordering integration and in franchise and multi-brand management, where a platform's origins show: a loyalty program built into one POS works differently from one built to connect to many.
Program Design & Earn Rules
6 requirementsEarn rules are the program's economics. Points per dollar, visit-based punch cards, tiers, bonus earn by item or daypart, paid memberships and credit for referrals decide what the program costs the brand and what it asks of the guest, and how easily marketing can change it as the business learns.
In the research, the 9 vendors score from 67 to 92 out of 100 on this section, one of the three closest in the report.
- Earn for Referrals and Engagement ActionsThe vendor must award points or rewards for non-purchase actions such as referrals, birthdays, profile completion or reviews.
- Paid Subscription Membership ProgramsThe vendor must support paid membership or subscription programs that give guests recurring perks for a fee.
- Bonus Earn Rules by Item, Daypart or ChannelThe vendor must let marketers set bonus earn multipliers for specific menu items, dayparts, days of week or ordering channels.
- Tiered Membership Status LevelsThe vendor must support tiered status levels with qualification thresholds and tier-specific benefits for members.
- Visit-Based Punch Card ProgramsThe vendor must support visit-based programs that reward guests after a set number of qualifying visits.
- Points-Per-Dollar Earn ProgramsThe vendor must support spend-based programs that award points per dollar spent with a configurable earn rate.
Rewards & Redemption
5 requirementsRewards are what guests come back for. A reward menu marketing can change on its own, redemption that works the same at the register, online and in the app, banked rewards and expiry rules shape both the guest experience and the liability the program carries.
In the research, the 9 vendors score from 55 to 90 out of 100 on this section.
- Experiential and Partner RewardsThe vendor must support non-menu rewards such as merchandise, experiences or partner offers alongside food and drink rewards.
- Points Expiration and Rolling Expiry RulesThe vendor must let the brand configure points and reward expiration, including inactivity-based or rolling expiry.
- Banked Rewards and Points-to-Dollar ConversionThe vendor must support converting points automatically into dollar-off rewards that guests can bank and use later.
- Reward Redemption at POS, Online and In-AppThe vendor must let guests redeem the same rewards at the register, in online ordering and in the brand's mobile app.
- Configurable Reward Catalog by Point LevelThe vendor must let marketers build a reward menu with items available at different point levels and change it without vendor help.
Offers & Promotions
5 requirementsOffers are where loyalty spend is won or wasted. Targeting by segment, unique codes, offers scheduled by location and daypart, stacking rules and tests against a control group decide whether a discount reaches the guests it was meant for and whether it brought in sales that would not have happened anyway.
In the research, the 9 vendors score from 50 to 85 out of 100 on this section.
- Offer A/B Testing with Control GroupsThe vendor must let marketers test offer variants against each other and against a no-offer control group.
- Offer Stacking and Exclusion RulesThe vendor must let the brand define which offers and rewards can be combined on one check and which are mutually exclusive.
- Limited-Time Offer Scheduling by Location and DaypartThe vendor must schedule offers to run only at selected locations, dates and dayparts.
- Single-Use and Multi-Use Promo CodesThe vendor must generate unique single-use codes and shared promo codes with usage limits for marketing and partner channels.
- Targeted Offers by Guest SegmentThe vendor must deliver offers only to guests in a defined segment, so a discount goes to the guests it is meant for.
Guest Profiles & Segmentation
5 requirementsA loyalty program is only as good as what it knows about guests. One profile across in-store, online, app and delivery, recognition at the register without the app, segments built without queries and feedback tied to the profile are what make targeting possible.
In the research, the 9 vendors score from 58 to 94 out of 100 on this section.
- Guest Feedback and Survey CaptureThe vendor must collect post-visit feedback or survey responses from guests and attach them to the guest profile.
- Card-Linked Recognition of Non-Member GuestsThe vendor must build profiles of guests who have not enrolled by recognizing repeat payment cards, so they can be counted and marketed to when permitted.
- Behavioral Segmentation BuilderThe vendor must let marketers build segments from visit frequency, recency, spend, items ordered, location and channel without writing queries.
- Guest Identification at POS Without the AppThe vendor must let guests identify themselves at the register by phone number, QR code or card so members without the app still earn.
- Unified Guest Profile Across ChannelsThe vendor must combine a guest's in-store, online, app and delivery activity into one profile.
Campaigns & Messaging
5 requirementsEmail, text, push and wallet passes are how the program reaches guests between visits. Sending from the loyalty platform itself, with restaurant templates and consent handled, saves a second tool and keeps the message tied to what the guest actually did.
In the research, the 9 vendors score from 55 to 85 out of 100 on this section, one of the three closest in the report.
- Apple Wallet and Google Wallet Loyalty PassesThe vendor must issue loyalty cards or offers as Apple Wallet and Google Wallet passes that update with the guest's balance.
- Restaurant Campaign Template LibraryThe vendor must provide ready-made campaign templates for common restaurant moments such as birthdays, new menu launches and holidays.
- Mobile Push and In-App MessagingThe vendor must send push notifications and in-app messages to guests through the brand's mobile app.
- SMS and MMS Messaging to GuestsThe vendor must send SMS and MMS campaigns to opted-in guests from the loyalty platform.
- Email Campaigns for Loyalty MembersThe vendor must design, schedule and send email campaigns to loyalty segments from the platform, with open and click reporting.
POS & Ordering Integration
6 requirementsLoyalty lives or dies at the point of sale. Certified POS integrations, real-time check data so rewards apply before payment, online ordering, kiosk and drive-thru recognition, delivery attribution and an offline mode decide whether staff and guests can use the program without friction.
In the research, the 9 vendors score from 42 to 90 out of 100 on this section, one of the three widest gaps in the report.
- Offline POS Mode for Loyalty TransactionsThe vendor must queue loyalty earn and redemption when a location loses connectivity and post them once it reconnects.
- Real-Time Check-Level Data CaptureThe vendor must receive item-level check data from the POS in real time, so points and offers apply before the guest pays.
- Kiosk and Drive-Thru Loyalty IdentificationThe vendor must let guests identify, earn and redeem at self-order kiosks and drive-thru lanes.
- Third-Party Delivery Order AttributionThe vendor must capture or attribute orders placed through third-party delivery marketplaces to guest profiles where data allows.
- Native Online Ordering Loyalty IntegrationThe vendor must integrate loyalty earn and redemption with the brand's first-party online ordering website and app.
- Certified Integrations with Major Restaurant POS SystemsThe vendor must publish a list of restaurant POS systems it integrates with, such as the common enterprise and cloud POS platforms.
Gift Cards & Stored Value
5 requirementsGift cards are a revenue line and a liability on the balance sheet. Physical and digital cards, a branded storefront, balances held in the guest's loyalty account, bulk orders and breakage and escheatment reporting decide whether one platform can run both programs or a second vendor is needed.
In the research, the 9 vendors score from 50 to 85 out of 100 on this section.
- Gift Card Breakage and Escheatment ReportingThe vendor must report outstanding gift card balances, breakage and dormant balances needed for unclaimed-property compliance.
- Corporate and Bulk Gift Card OrdersThe vendor must support bulk and corporate gift card orders with custom amounts and delivery to many recipients.
- Stored-Value Balance Linked to Loyalty ProfileThe vendor must hold gift card or prepaid balances in the guest's loyalty account so guests pay and earn in one step.
- Branded E-Gift Card Online StorefrontThe vendor must provide a branded online store where guests buy and send digital gift cards.
- Physical and Digital Restaurant Gift Card IssuanceThe vendor must issue and process both plastic and digital gift cards redeemable across the brand's locations.
Fraud & Liability Controls
5 requirementsPoints are a currency, and they attract abuse from guests and staff. Fraud alerts, controls on employee abuse, earn and redemption limits, account takeover protection and reporting of outstanding points for finance protect both the program's margin and the brand's books.
In the research, the 9 vendors score from 50 to 85 out of 100 on this section.
- Account Takeover Protection for Guest Loyalty AccountsThe vendor must protect guest accounts from takeover with measures such as verification codes, bot detection or login anomaly alerts.
- Outstanding Points Liability Reporting for FinanceThe vendor must report the outstanding value of unredeemed points and rewards for the brand's financial accounting.
- Velocity Limits on Earn and RedemptionThe vendor must let the brand cap how often or how much a guest can earn or redeem in a period.
- Employee Loyalty Abuse ControlsThe vendor must detect or block staff from crediting their own accounts or applying guests' unclaimed visits to themselves.
- Loyalty Fraud Detection and AlertsThe vendor must flag suspicious loyalty activity, such as abnormal earn patterns or duplicate accounts, and alert admins.
Franchise & Multi-Brand Management
5 requirementsFranchise systems and restaurant groups need one program that works across owners and brands. Multi-brand administration, franchisee opt-in to promotions, permissions limited to a franchisee's own stores, a currency shared across sister brands and settlement of rewards redeemed at another owner's store decide whether the platform fits the business structure.
In the research, the 9 vendors score from 30 to 75 out of 100 on this section.
- Franchise Reward Settlement and Reimbursement ReportingThe vendor must report rewards earned at one location and redeemed at another so franchisees can settle costs between them.
- Coalition Earn and Redeem Across Sister BrandsThe vendor must let guests earn and redeem one currency across several brands owned by the same restaurant group.
- Location-Level Permissions for FranchiseesThe vendor must give franchisees access to reporting and local offers for their own locations only.
- Franchisee Opt-In and Local Offer ControlThe vendor must let franchisees opt in to brand promotions and run approved local offers within brand guardrails.
- Multi-Brand Loyalty Under One AccountThe vendor must run separate loyalty programs for multiple restaurant brands from one administrative account.
Platform and vendor
These nine sections cover the product underneath and the company behind it: automation, integrations, data, administration, security, implementation, support, pricing and the vendor's standing. They are easy to leave until contract stage. Pricing is where vendors in the research are hardest to compare, because few publish loyalty prices and many bundle loyalty with a POS or ordering subscription.
Workflow, Automation & Intelligence
5 requirementsAutomation is where a loyalty platform saves marketing time: lifecycle journeys, triggers on visits and lapses, churn scores and offers chosen for each guest. It is also where vendors' claims are hardest to verify, so ask to see it working on your own data.
In the research, the 9 vendors score from 45 to 90 out of 100 on this section.
- AI-Assisted Offer and Campaign RecommendationsThe vendor must document AI or machine-learning features that recommend offers, audiences or send times to restaurant marketers.
- Next-Best-Offer Personalization per GuestThe vendor must select offers for each guest automatically from that guest's order history and preferences rather than sending one offer to a whole segment.
- Predictive Lapse and Churn Scoring for GuestsThe vendor must score guests on their likelihood to lapse and let marketers target win-back campaigns from that score.
- Trigger-Based Automation on Guest Visit EventsThe vendor must fire messages or offers automatically from guest events such as a first visit, a set number of visits or a period without a visit.
- Automated Guest Lifecycle JourneysThe vendor must provide multi-step automated journeys for onboarding, birthday, anniversary and win-back stages without manual sends.
Integrations, APIs & Ecosystem
6 requirementsLoyalty sits between the POS, the ordering channels, the app and the marketing stack. A documented API, webhooks, a mobile SDK, connectors to email and data platforms, card linking and links to Wi-Fi, reservations and reviews decide how much data moves on its own.
In the research, the 9 vendors score from 35 to 85 out of 100 on this section, one of the three widest gaps in the report.
- Wi-Fi, Reservation and Review Platform IntegrationsThe vendor must document integrations with guest Wi-Fi, reservation or waitlist, and review platforms that add guests or events to loyalty profiles.
- Payment Card Linking for Loyalty RecognitionThe vendor must recognize members and award loyalty credit from a linked payment card without a code, phone number or app scan.
- Marketing and Customer Data Platform ConnectorsThe vendor must offer prebuilt connectors to email service providers, customer data platforms or ad platforms for sharing loyalty audiences.
- Branded Mobile App SDK for LoyaltyThe vendor must provide a mobile SDK or white-label app so a restaurant brand can embed loyalty in its own iOS and Android apps.
- Webhooks for Loyalty EventsThe vendor must send webhooks for loyalty events such as enrollment, points earned and reward redeemed to the buyer's systems.
- Public Developer API for Restaurant LoyaltyThe vendor must publish developer documentation for an API covering members, points balances, rewards and offers.
Data Management, Reporting & Analytics
6 requirementsLoyalty reporting is how a brand proves the program pays. A program dashboard, incremental lift against a control group, frequency and spend by location, cohort retention, item affinity and raw data delivered to the warehouse separate a program that is measured from one that is assumed to work.
In the research, the 9 vendors score from 50 to 83 out of 100 on this section.
- Menu Item Affinity Analysis for MembersThe vendor must report which menu items loyalty members order and buy together, so offers can be built around item preferences.
- Cohort Retention Analysis for Loyalty MembersThe vendor must report retention and repeat-visit rates by enrollment cohort over time.
- Raw Loyalty Data Export to a Data WarehouseThe vendor must deliver transaction-level loyalty and guest data to the buyer's data warehouse or storage on a schedule or by data share.
- Guest Frequency and Spend Reporting by LocationThe vendor must report visit frequency, average check and spend for members, broken out by location and region.
- Incremental Lift Measurement for Loyalty CampaignsThe vendor must measure the incremental sales of campaigns and offers against a holdout or control group, not only redemption counts.
- Loyalty Program Performance DashboardThe vendor must provide a standard dashboard showing enrollment, active members, member sales share and redemption rates.
Architecture, Configuration & Administration
5 requirementsSelf-service configuration, a branded guest experience the brand controls, a sandbox, an uptime commitment and proven capacity for national promotions decide how much the program can change without the vendor, and whether it holds up on the busiest day of the year.
In the research, the 9 vendors score from 38 to 90 out of 100 on this section, one of the three widest gaps in the report.
- Sandbox Environment for Loyalty TestingThe vendor must provide a test or sandbox environment where program rules, offers and integrations can be tried before going live.
- Peak-Volume Scalability for Restaurant TransactionsThe vendor must show its loyalty platform handles peak restaurant volume, such as national promotions across thousands of locations, through published figures or case studies.
- Branded Guest Web and App Experience ConfigurationThe vendor must let the brand configure the look, copy and layout of guest-facing loyalty web pages and app screens without vendor engineering work.
- Self-Service Loyalty Program ConfigurationThe vendor must let restaurant marketers change earn rules, rewards and offers in an admin console without code or a vendor services ticket.
- Uptime Commitment for Loyalty PlatformThe vendor must publish a service-level commitment or status page reporting the availability of its loyalty platform.
Security, Privacy, Compliance & Auditability
6 requirementsA loyalty platform holds guest personal data and, often, stored value. Independent security attestations, PCI scope, consent for text and email, state privacy law support, data access and deletion requests and audit logs matter more as the member base grows.
In the research, the 9 vendors score from 58 to 83 out of 100 on this section, one of the three closest in the report.
- Role-Based Access and Audit Logs for Loyalty AdminsThe vendor must restrict loyalty admin functions by role and log changes to points, rewards and guest records with user and timestamp.
- Guest Data Access and Deletion RequestsThe vendor must provide a documented process or tool to fulfill guest requests to access or delete their loyalty data.
- State Privacy Law Support for Restaurant Guest DataThe vendor must document how its loyalty product supports CCPA and other U.S. state privacy laws, including financial-incentive notices for loyalty programs.
- Guest Consent Management for SMS and Email MarketingThe vendor must capture and enforce guest opt-in and opt-out for SMS and email in line with TCPA and CAN-SPAM requirements.
- PCI DSS Scope for Loyalty and Stored Value DataThe vendor must state its PCI DSS validation level for any cardholder or stored-value data its loyalty product handles.
- SOC 2 Type II Report for Loyalty PlatformThe vendor must hold a current SOC 2 Type II report that covers its restaurant loyalty platform.
Implementation, Migration, Training & Adoption
5 requirementsSwitching loyalty platforms puts members' balances at risk. A stated launch timeline, migration of members and points without lost value, staff training for enrollment, launch marketing support and a pilot before the chain-wide rollout decide how smoothly guests make the move.
In the research, the 9 vendors score from 50 to 90 out of 100 on this section.
- Phased Loyalty Rollout by Location or MarketThe vendor must support launching the program in a pilot set of locations or markets before a chain-wide rollout.
- Loyalty Launch Marketing SupportThe vendor must provide launch assets or services, such as in-store signage templates and enrollment campaigns, for a new program.
- Store Staff Training for Loyalty EnrollmentThe vendor must provide training materials for restaurant staff on enrolling guests and handling loyalty at the counter or table.
- Member and Points Balance Migration from Prior ProgramThe vendor must migrate existing members, points balances and earned rewards from a previous loyalty provider without guests losing value.
- Loyalty Launch Timeline for Multi-Unit ChainsThe vendor must state a typical implementation timeline for a multi-unit restaurant chain, supported by case studies or documentation.
Support & Customer Success
5 requirementsLoyalty problems show up at the counter and in guests' inboxes. Support during restaurant hours, a named success manager, help with guest issues such as missing points, strategy services and a public help center decide how long a problem stays a problem.
In the research, the 9 vendors score from 67 to 100 out of 100 on this section.
- Help Center for Restaurant Loyalty OperatorsThe vendor must maintain a public help center or knowledge base covering loyalty setup, offers and reporting.
- Loyalty Strategy and Program Benchmarking ServicesThe vendor must offer strategy services that benchmark the buyer's program against restaurant peers and recommend changes.
- Guest-Facing Loyalty Support HandlingThe vendor must offer a service or tooling to resolve guest loyalty issues, such as missing points, on the brand's behalf.
- Restaurant-Hours Technical Support CoverageThe vendor must provide technical support during restaurant operating hours, including evenings and weekends.
- Dedicated Loyalty Customer Success ManagerThe vendor must assign a named customer success or account manager to multi-unit restaurant customers.
Pricing & Contracts
5 requirementsLoyalty is priced per location, per member, per transaction or bundled with a POS, and messaging costs may sit on top. Published pricing, a clear fee structure, disclosed messaging costs and the right to take member data at the end of the contract make the total cost comparable before a sales process starts.
In the research, the 9 vendors score from 25 to 58 out of 100 on this section.
- Bundled Loyalty Pricing with POS or OrderingThe vendor must state whether loyalty is priced on its own or bundled with a POS, payments or online ordering subscription.
- Loyalty Contract Term and Guest Data PortabilityThe vendor must state its standard contract term and confirm the brand can export its member and points data when the contract ends.
- SMS and Messaging Pass-Through CostsThe vendor must disclose whether SMS, email and push messages are included or billed per message on top of the platform fee.
- Per-Location Versus Per-Member Fee StructureThe vendor must state whether loyalty fees are charged per location, per active member, per transaction or as a flat platform fee.
- Published Pricing for Restaurant LoyaltyThe vendor must publish pricing or pricing tiers for its restaurant loyalty product on its website.
Company & Product Overview
5 requirementsA vendor's focus and standing shape its roadmap. Whether it was built for restaurants, which multi-unit brands run it, how often it ships updates and who owns it are all part of choosing a program the brand will run for years.
In the research, the 9 vendors score from 60 to 95 out of 100 on this section.
- Restaurant Segment Fit Across Service ModelsThe vendor must show named restaurant customers running its loyalty product across quick-service, fast-casual and full-service formats.
- Loyalty Vendor Ownership and Corporate BackingThe vendor must disclose who owns the loyalty product, including any parent company, acquisition history or investors, in public filings or press.
- Loyalty Product Roadmap and Release CadenceThe vendor must publish release notes or a product update log showing regular feature releases to its restaurant loyalty product within the last twelve months.
- Restaurant Industry Focus of Loyalty ProductThe vendor must position its loyalty product primarily for restaurants, with restaurant-specific features documented on its website or help center.
- Multi-Unit Restaurant Loyalty Customer BaseThe vendor must publish the number of restaurant brands or locations running its loyalty program and name multi-unit chains among its customers.
