Nine restaurant loyalty platforms scored on 95 requirements in 18 sections. Thanx leads with 81%, one point ahead of Punchh, and Capillary Technologies is third.
Restaurants
Loyalty
Edition 1 · November 2026
Thanx leads Olive's evaluation of restaurant loyalty software with 81%, one point ahead of Punchh (80%), with Capillary Technologies third (72%). Paytronix follows with 71% and Incentivio with 66%, Fishbowl Loyalty, Givex and Olo Loyalty share sixth place at 65%, and Toast Loyalty is ninth with 60%.
The order changes with the job. On the nine restaurant loyalty sections, Punchh has the highest group score (85%), ahead of Thanx (80%) and Capillary Technologies (77%). Paytronix scores highest on guest profiles (94%), Punchh on earn rules (92%) and POS and ordering integration (90%), and Thanx on support (100%). Pricing and contracts is the lowest-scoring section for most platforms, because few publish loyalty prices. Architecture, configuration and administration is where the platforms differ most, from 38% to 90%.
Rankings · overall score and section range (0–100)
Overall scoreWeakest to strongest section
0255075100
OverallRestaurant loyaltyPlatform and vendor
1Thanx
818081
2Punchh (by PAR Technology)
808576
3Capillary Technologies
727768
4Paytronix
717368
5Incentivio
667062
6Fishbowl Loyalty
656960
6Givex
656763
6Olo Loyalty
656763
9Toast Loyalty
605862
Thanx leads on 81. 3 vendors share sixth place on 65. The other 8 vendors sit within 20 points of each other, while every vendor's own weakest and strongest sections are at least 32 points apart.
Data table
Rank
Vendor
Overall
Weakest section
Strongest section
Restaurant loyalty
Platform and vendor
1
Thanx
81
50
100
80
81
2
Punchh (by PAR Technology)
80
38
95
85
76
3
Capillary Technologies
72
58
90
77
68
4
Paytronix
71
45
94
73
68
5
Incentivio
66
25
85
70
62
6
Fishbowl Loyalty
65
33
81
69
60
6
Givex
65
38
85
67
63
6
Olo Loyalty
65
33
90
67
63
9
Toast Loyalty
60
30
88
58
62
Key findings
Thanx ranks first with 81 out of 100 and has the highest score in 7 of 18 sections, including Support & Customer Success (100).
Punchh (by PAR Technology) is second with 80 and leads 8 sections, including Company & Product Overview (95).
Three vendors tie for sixth on 65: Fishbowl Loyalty, Givex and Olo Loyalty. They reach it differently: Givex scores strong on 16 requirements, Fishbowl Loyalty on 9.
Vendors outside the top two lead sections of their own: Capillary Technologies on Pricing & Contracts (58), Givex on Security, Privacy, Compliance & Auditability (83) and Paytronix on Guest Profiles & Segmentation (94).
What is restaurant loyalty software?
Restaurant loyalty software runs the program that rewards guests for coming back: how they earn points or visits, what they can redeem, the offers and messages that bring them back between visits, and how they are recognized at the register, online and in the app. For a multi-unit restaurant brand it also means one guest profile across channels, rules that hold up against fraud, gift cards and stored value, reporting that shows whether the program pays, and control across company-owned and franchised stores.
This report compares 9 platforms, from loyalty products built for restaurants to enterprise loyalty suites and loyalty programs that come with a POS. Each is scored against the same 95 requirements in 18 sections: nine on restaurant loyalty and nine on the platform and the vendor behind it. Como, Craver, SpotOn Loyalty and Square Loyalty were also researched and scored below the nine published here; three of them tied for tenth place, so the report stops at nine.
Every score comes from research into public information. Where no public evidence was found for a requirement, that requirement is left out of the vendor's score rather than counted as zero. Public information was thinner for some vendors than others, so some scores rest on fewer requirements; the vendor profiles say where.
How this was evaluated
Where vendors differ
Every section score, in report order. The last column gives the lowest and highest score in each row; the three widest gaps are in bold. One section, POS & Ordering Integration, opens to show each vendor's score on its 6 requirements.
Section scores by vendor (0–100)
Below 4545–5960–6970–7980 and above
Requirement section
Thanx
Punchh (by PAR Technology)
Capillary Technologies
Paytronix
Incentivio
Fishbowl Loyalty
Givex
Olo Loyalty
Toast Loyalty
Low–high
Restaurant loyalty
Program Design & Earn Rules6 requirements
85
92
88
88
80
75
80
75
67
67–92
Rewards & Redemption5 requirements
80
90
90
70
65
63
70
75
55
55–90
Offers & Promotions5 requirements
85
80
85
70
50
81
58
65
69
50–85
Guest Profiles & Segmentation5 requirements
90
90
69
94
75
75
58
85
75
58–94
Campaigns & Messaging5 requirements
85
75
70
65
69
81
55
60
60
55–85
POS & Ordering Integration
85
90
58
67
81
63
67
58
42
42–90
Offline POS Mode for Loyalty Transactions
–
75
–
50
–
–
–
0
0
0–75
Real-Time Check-Level Data Capture
75
75
–
75
–
–
–
75
50
50–75
Kiosk and Drive-Thru Loyalty Identification
100
100
50
50
50
50
100
50
50
50–100
Third-Party Delivery Order Attribution
50
100
–
50
75
75
–
50
50
50–100
Native Online Ordering Loyalty Integration
100
100
75
100
100
75
100
100
100
75–100
Certified Integrations with Major Restaurant POS Systems
100
–
50
75
100
50
0
75
0
0–100
Each requirement is scored 0 to 10 and shown here on the same 0–100 scale; the section score is the average of its requirements. The other 17 sections open the same way in the full evaluation, with a free Olive account.
Implementation, Migration, Training & Adoption5 requirements
90
80
63
65
50
50
56
56
75
50–90
Support & Customer Success5 requirements
100
85
67
69
83
75
67
69
80
67–100
Pricing & Contracts5 requirements
50
38
58
45
25
33
38
33
31
25–58
Company & Product Overview5 requirements
70
95
60
88
65
75
70
90
88
60–95
Vendors separate most on Architecture, Configuration & Administration (38 to 90) and least on Program Design & Earn Rules (67 to 92).
What you prioritize
An overall ranking treats every requirement as equally important. No buyer does. In a real evaluation a few requirement areas decide the outcome and others barely matter, and how you weight them changes which vendor comes out ahead.
The radar shows how. Open Sections to switch off the areas that matter less to your business, and select up to four vendors to compare. Every score is recalculated on the sections you leave on, and the list re-sorts as you go.
In this report the order moves when only part of it counts. Toast Loyalty is ninth on the overall score and seventh on the 9 Platform and vendor sections alone.
Vendor radar · score by section (0–100)
Vendors
Scores on all sections. Up to 4 vendors on the chart at once.
All 18 sections are on, so these are the report's overall scores. Open Sections to change what counts.
Data table
Section
Thanx
Punchh (by PAR Technology)
Capillary Technologies
Paytronix
Program Design & Earn Rules
85
92
88
88
Rewards & Redemption
80
90
90
70
Offers & Promotions
85
80
85
70
Guest Profiles & Segmentation
90
90
69
94
Campaigns & Messaging
85
75
70
65
POS & Ordering Integration
85
90
58
67
Gift Cards & Stored Value
58
75
–
85
Fraud & Liability Controls
67
85
75
56
Franchise & Multi-Brand Management
67
75
69
60
Workflow, Automation & Intelligence
85
90
90
85
Integrations, APIs & Ecosystem
85
85
63
75
Data Management, Reporting & Analytics
83
63
81
70
Architecture, Configuration & Administration
90
70
60
55
Security, Privacy, Compliance & Auditability
75
65
65
67
Implementation, Migration, Training & Adoption
90
80
63
65
Support & Customer Success
100
85
67
69
Pricing & Contracts
50
38
58
45
Company & Product Overview
70
95
60
88
This report uses one requirement set. To rank vendors on your own requirements, create your own report.
How each score is built
Two vendors can reach the same overall score in different ways. One scores strong on many requirements and limited on others. Another scores partial almost everywhere. The bands show which is which.
That matters for how you buy. If you want the strongest product for specific functions and are willing to integrate other tools around it, look for the most requirements in the strong band in the areas you care about. If you want one system that covers most needs without adding others, look for the fewest requirements in the limited band.
Requirements by score band · 95 requirements
Strong (8–10)Partial (5–7.9)Limited (below 5)
Thanx
4141
81
Punchh (by PAR Technology)
4044
80
Capillary Technologies
2551
72
Paytronix
2461
71
Incentivio
2050
66
Fishbowl Loyalty
946
65
Givex
1644
65
Olo Loyalty
1662
65
Toast Loyalty
205710
60
3 vendors share a score of 65. Givex gets there with 16 strong requirements; Fishbowl Loyalty with 9 strong and 46 partial.
Data table
Vendor
Strong
Partial
Limited
Overall
Thanx
41
41
1
81
Punchh (by PAR Technology)
40
44
1
80
Capillary Technologies
25
51
1
72
Paytronix
24
61
1
71
Incentivio
20
50
4
66
Fishbowl Loyalty
9
46
2
65
Givex
16
44
2
65
Olo Loyalty
16
62
3
65
Toast Loyalty
20
57
10
60
The vendors in this report
In order of overall score; vendors on the same score are listed alphabetically.
Thanx is a guest engagement platform for restaurants that combines loyalty, CRM, marketing and digital ordering. It has the highest overall score (81%) and is in the strong band on 41 requirements, the most in this report. It scores highest on support (100%), administration and implementation (90% each) and guest profiles (90%). Pricing (50%) and gift cards (58%) are its weakest sections.
Overall
81
Restaurant loyalty
80
Platform and vendor
81
Score bands
41 of 83 requirements strong
Scores highest on Support & Customer Success (100), Guest Profiles & Segmentation (90) and Architecture, Configuration & Administration (90). Scores lowest on Pricing & Contracts (50).
Best fit:Multi-unit restaurant brands that want loyalty, guest data and marketing in one platform with hands-on support.
Punchh is a loyalty and guest engagement platform for restaurant chains, owned by PAR Technology. It has the highest score on the restaurant loyalty sections (85%) and leads on company and product overview (95%), earn rules (92%) and POS and ordering integration (90%), with rewards, guest profiles and automation also at 90%. Pricing (38%) and data management and reporting (63%) are its weakest sections.
Overall
80
Restaurant loyalty
85
Platform and vendor
76
Score bands
40 of 85 requirements strong
Scores highest on Company & Product Overview (95), Program Design & Earn Rules (92) and Rewards & Redemption (90). Scores lowest on Pricing & Contracts (38).
Best fit:Large quick-service and fast-casual chains that need deep POS and ordering integration and flexible earn rules.
Capillary Technologies is an enterprise loyalty and customer engagement platform that serves retail, restaurants and other consumer brands. It scores best on rewards and automation (90% each), earn rules (88%) and offers (85%), and its pricing score (58%) is the highest in this report. POS and ordering integration (58%), administration and company and product overview (60% each) are its weakest sections. The research found no public evidence on its gift card capabilities, so that section is left out of its score.
Overall
72
Restaurant loyalty
77
Platform and vendor
68
Score bands
25 of 77 requirements strong
Scores highest on Rewards & Redemption (90), Workflow, Automation & Intelligence (90) and Program Design & Earn Rules (88). Scores lowest on Pricing & Contracts (58).
Best fit:Restaurant groups that run loyalty alongside retail or other consumer brands and want an enterprise loyalty engine.
Paytronix is a guest engagement platform for restaurants and convenience stores covering loyalty, gift cards, online ordering and marketing. It scores highest of the nine on guest profiles (94%) and shares the highest gift card score (85%), and scores 88% on earn rules and company and product overview. Pricing (45%), administration (55%) and fraud and liability controls (56%) are its weakest sections.
Overall
71
Restaurant loyalty
73
Platform and vendor
68
Score bands
24 of 86 requirements strong
Scores highest on Guest Profiles & Segmentation (94), Program Design & Earn Rules (88) and Company & Product Overview (88). Scores lowest on Pricing & Contracts (45).
Best fit:Multi-unit restaurant brands that want loyalty and gift cards from one vendor with a detailed guest profile.
Incentivio is a guest engagement platform for restaurants that combines loyalty, marketing automation and digital ordering. It scores best on automation (85%), support (83%), POS and ordering integration (81%) and earn rules (80%). Pricing (25%), the lowest section score in this report, and integrations (35%) are its weakest sections, because little public information covers its prices or its developer tools.
Overall
66
Restaurant loyalty
70
Platform and vendor
62
Score bands
20 of 74 requirements strong
Scores highest on Workflow, Automation & Intelligence (85), Support & Customer Success (83) and POS & Ordering Integration (81). Scores lowest on Pricing & Contracts (25).
Best fit:Restaurant brands that want loyalty, automated marketing and their own ordering channels from one vendor.
Fishbowl is a guest marketing and data company for restaurants, and Fishbowl Loyalty is its loyalty product. It scores best on offers and campaigns (81% each), earn rules, guest profiles, security and support (75% each). Administration (38%) and pricing (33%) are its weakest sections. Public information on Fishbowl Loyalty was limited: the research found evidence for fewer requirements than for most vendors here, and those without evidence are left out of its score rather than counted against it.
Overall
65
Restaurant loyalty
69
Platform and vendor
60
Score bands
9 of 57 requirements strong
Scores highest on Offers & Promotions (81), Campaigns & Messaging (81) and Program Design & Earn Rules (75). Scores lowest on Pricing & Contracts (33).
Best fit:Restaurant brands whose priority is targeted offers and guest marketing on top of their loyalty program.
Givex provides gift card, loyalty and POS products for restaurants and retailers. It shares the highest gift card score in this report (85%), has the highest security score (83%) and scores 80% on earn rules. Pricing (38%) is its weakest section. Public information on Givex's loyalty product was limited: the research found evidence for fewer requirements than for most vendors here, including none on fraud and liability controls, and requirements without evidence are left out of its score rather than counted against it.
Overall
65
Restaurant loyalty
67
Platform and vendor
63
Score bands
16 of 62 requirements strong
Scores highest on Gift Cards & Stored Value (85), Security, Privacy, Compliance & Auditability (83) and Program Design & Earn Rules (80). Scores lowest on Pricing & Contracts (38).
Best fit:Restaurant brands that want gift cards and stored value at the center of their loyalty program.
Olo Loyalty is the loyalty product of Olo, the restaurant ordering platform, built on its acquisition of Spendgo. It scores best on company and product overview (90%), guest profiles (85%), earn rules, rewards and data management (75% each). Pricing (33%) and integrations (42%) are its weakest sections.
Overall
65
Restaurant loyalty
67
Platform and vendor
63
Score bands
16 of 81 requirements strong
Scores highest on Company & Product Overview (90), Guest Profiles & Segmentation (85) and Program Design & Earn Rules (75). Scores lowest on Pricing & Contracts (33).
Best fit:Restaurant brands already on Olo ordering that want loyalty tied to the same platform.
Toast Loyalty is the loyalty program built into the Toast restaurant POS. It scores best on company and product overview (88%), support (80%), implementation (75%) and guest profiles (75%). Its loyalty runs on Toast's own POS and ordering rather than across other systems, and it supports one rewards program at a time, so multi-brand management (30%) and POS and ordering integration (42%) are its weakest sections.
Overall
60
Restaurant loyalty
58
Platform and vendor
62
Score bands
20 of 87 requirements strong
Scores highest on Company & Product Overview (88), Support & Customer Success (80) and Guest Profiles & Segmentation (75). Scores lowest on Franchise & Multi-Brand Management (30).
Best fit:Single-brand restaurants and groups already running Toast POS that want loyalty with no separate integration.
Summary
This report scores 9 vendors against 95 requirements in 18 sections. Thanx ranks first with 81 out of 100, Punchh (by PAR Technology) is second with 80 and three vendors tie for sixth on 65.
Vendors separate most on Architecture, Configuration & Administration (38 to 90) and least on Program Design & Earn Rules (67 to 92). Every vendor's own strongest and weakest sections are at least 32 points apart, so the overall order says little about any one section.
No single ranking fits every buyer. A position here reflects one requirement set with every requirement weighted equally. Use the section scores to see where each vendor is strongest, the score bands to tell a specialist from an all-rounder, and the radar to see how the order changes with your priorities.
Quick answers
What is the best restaurant loyalty software?
In this report Thanx has the highest overall score (81%), one point ahead of Punchh (80%) and nine ahead of Capillary Technologies (72%). Punchh has the highest score on the nine restaurant loyalty sections (85%). The order changes with the sections a buyer prioritizes, which the radar chart on this page lets you test.
Which restaurant loyalty platforms does this report cover?
Nine platforms: Thanx, Punchh, Capillary Technologies, Paytronix, Incentivio, Fishbowl Loyalty, Givex, Olo Loyalty and Toast Loyalty. Como, Craver, SpotOn Loyalty and Square Loyalty were also researched and scored below the nine.
Which loyalty platform is strongest on POS and ordering integration?
Punchh scores highest on POS and ordering integration (90%), followed by Thanx (85%) and Incentivio (81%). The section covers certified POS integrations, real-time check data, online ordering, kiosk and drive-thru recognition, delivery attribution and offline mode.
How were the restaurant loyalty platforms scored?
Each platform is scored from 0 to 10 on 95 requirements in 18 sections. A platform's score is the percentage of the best possible score across the requirements where public evidence was found. In this edition every answer comes from Olive research into public information; no vendor has supplied responses.
Can I rank loyalty platforms on my own requirements?
Yes. This report uses one requirement set. In Olive you can build your own requirements and score the platforms that matter to you against them.
Run this evaluation on your own requirements
Olive builds a ranking from what your team needs, not from a fixed list. Start from a category and score the vendors that matter to you.
The 692 scores in this edition were produced by Olive's AI analysis and reviewed by an Olive analyst before publication. The analysis reads public information: product documentation, vendor websites and other published sources. It also draws on answers vendors have given to buyers in evaluations run in Olive, with the buyers never identified. No vendor has responded to this report's requirements directly.
What the scores represent
This is the research a buyer would do before speaking to a sales team, done faster. A score reflects the information available when the edition was built. A capability that exists but is not documented can score lower than the product deserves.
Vendor responses
A vendor's own response is the most accurate source. Olive often invites vendors to respond, and any vendor can ask to. Olive updates its reports to reflect the responses it receives. Submit vendor responses.
Limits of one ranking
This ranking uses one requirement set, with every requirement weighted equally, as of November 2026. Your requirements and priorities will produce a different order. The most accurate evaluation is one run on your own requirements, with vendors responding directly.
Independence
Olive has no commercial relationship with any vendor in this report. No vendor pays to be included, scored or ranked.